Showing posts with label Ellen Robertson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ellen Robertson. Show all posts

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Cloud 9

by Caryl Churchill

seen at the National Theatre (Lyttleton) on 14 November 2026

Dominic Cooke directs a cast of seven in a major revival of Caryl Churchill's 1979 play Cloud 9. A dazzling and at times bewildering examination of entrenched attitudes to class, sexuality and race as they are perpetuated and modified over the decades, this play requires bravura performances from its cast. The first act is set in an unnamed British colony in Africa in Victorian times where Clive (Sam Troughton) and his wife Betty (Stuart Thompson) preside over a family and small community rife with concealed passion and hypocritical outrage, with a black servant Joshua (Eloka Ivo) playing the white man's game until a sudden breaking point. Adulterous affairs can be connived at but gay relationships are apparently beyond the pale. Edward (Ellen Robertson), Clive and Betty's young son, clearly more interested in his sister's dolls than in manly pursuits, nonetheless craves his father's approval and attempts to learn the codes of manliness expected of him while quickly taking advantage of the grey areas - incriminating servants, for example. His sister Victoria is so repressed that she is represented only by a doll passed around and occasionally tossed from governess to mother. All this is presented inside a massive gilt picture frame, and in a weirdly stilted and bombastic style, almost like an extended Monty Python skit or as deliberate farce, creating a distancing effect during which the audience is constantly wrong-footed as more and more clandestine secrets are hinted at. 

The audience is required to leave the auditorium during the interval (usually it is possible to stay put if one is not interested in interval drinks). The hectoring insistence in the announcement is not surprising, as a radical transformation is required for the second act: the gilt frame has been destroyed and pieces of it are lying haphazardly on the stage, with the voluminous red velvet curtains collapsed over the front rows of the auditorium. Audience members who took those seats for Act One are now seated on the stage itself as silent witnesses of the interplay between various characters in the 1970s as they negotiate the dizzying "freedoms" promised by the huge shift in cultural norms of the 1960s. Edward (now Stuart Thompson) is a young gay man hoping for a stable relationship, which seems too much like marriage to his more promiscuous partner Gerry (Eloka Ivo). His sister Victoria (Charlotte Ritchie) is married to Martin (Tom Mothersdale), a man lost in the toils of trying to be a feminist, but she becomes closely involved with Lin (Rebecca Humphries) and her little girl Cathy (Sam Troughton eating the wallpaper as a spoiled three-or-four year old bargaining for ice cream and TV rights). In the meantime their mother Betty (now Ellen Robertson, channelling Prunella Scales playing the Queen or Sybil Fawlty in pink twinset and pearls) is contemplating divorce from her (unseen) husband Clive and trying to reconnect with her children.

It's all very confusing as an immediate experience, with the stylised Victorian stiffness threatening to become wearisome or completely off-putting, and the vertiginous shift of tone between the two acts leaving us scrabbling to make sense of it all. There's a danger too of spending too much time trying to identify the actors behind the roles in the two parts. Sam Troughton with his full beard is unmistakeable (and all the more hilarious as a little girl), but it took me ages to "recognise" Stuart Thompson as Edward in the second half after his strangely magisterial performance as Betty in the first, and equally Ellen Roberson's transformation from the boy Eddy to the mother Betty was phenomenal.

The play is certainly unconventional, and its frank discussion of fluid relationships and sexual experiences must have been bracing (to say the least) in 1979. Now, on the other side of the AIDS epidemic and the various disillusionments of continued double standards, misogyny, homophobia and racism, the mixture of hopefulness and confusion in the second act is often quite poignant. As the initial perplexity at being confronted with two such unexpectedly different acts fades, it is possible to recognise the subtle and dangerous continuities Churchill was exploring. The program note on the setting states

    Act One takes place in a British colony in Africa in Victorian times.
    Act Two takes place in London in 1979.
    But for the characters it is 25 years later.

This goes some way to explaining (or at least accounting for) the odd juxtapositions, as does the knowledge that Caryl Churchill wrote the play after extensive workshopping with the original cast, drawing on their own experiences of the issues she was addressing.

I first saw this play in Sydney not long after its premiere; it was fascinating then and remains fascinating now.